Although the FDA regulates breast pumps as they are considered medical devices, the term "hospital grade" is neither recognized nor monitored by the FDA. Just dont overcharge its battery so you can use its battery life usage of 800-1000 hours of pumping. Group Leaders arent expected to spend any additional time in the community, and are not held to a set schedule. The Baby Buddha is a great mobility pump. More on the different types of breast pumps here. There is a new trend toward mobility during pumping. Of course, just like anything, there's a learning curve, but it . Included is everything Naturally, the manual pumps are the quietest due to the lack of a motor, with the Medela Harmony and the Haakaa earning top ranks in this metric. & Briefcases Programs , AC Adapter, (2) Extra Valves and However, if you need a non-electric pump and lack the hand strength or dexterity required of the Harmony, the Haakaa released an impressive amount of milk in our tests for a passive letdown system. the medela doesnt have the short pumps followed by the long pump sequence. Yikes! Or, maybe you just want a Spectra pump comparison between the S2 and S9. The Spectra 1 is relatively light and has a handy carry handle but is not the best for on-the-go pumping sessions. Dr. Spurrier is a mother of two, a board-certified pediatrician, and a Fellow of the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP). I would note that the wireless pumps may not be strong enough for some people. ), Best Portable Bassinets (Travel Light for Parents On The Go! (1) Power adaptor We had breastfeeding mothers use the pumps and provide feedback on their experience and research with other users. Find advice, support and good company (and some stuff just for fun). features of the Spectra S2 Plus. When you purchase through our links, we may earn a commission. The Spectra S1 is portable, but the Spectra S2 isn't. The Spectra S1 costs more ($200), while the Spectra S2 is a bit more affordable ($159) The Spectra S1 weighs a bit more (2.42 lbs), while the Spectra S2 weighs a bit less (2.0 lbs) The Spectra S1 comes in . Unfortunately, the Buddha is loud and makes a rhythmic buzzing sound you can hear over the phone and across the room. You don't specifically mention having used the Spectra. The narrower-mouth Medela bottles don't seem to fit, but we did get several AVENT bottles to fit without any issues. I love the idea of the Buddha for portability and I've heard it is strong, but the sound level is important to me. Advertisement Coins. (2) Tubing The Willow Gen 3 is probably one of the easiest as the milk goes directly into the collection container or bag and does not require any milk transfer. If you pump more than 3x/week, a double electric pump is a very worthwhile investment. Both the Spectra S9 vs Baby Buddha has a built-in rechargeable battery, which means you can use it without having to plug it into a socket. Each individual responds differently to a breast pump. Its a very affordable wireless breast pump option. I havent had any issues. adaptor, (1) Battery pack (8 - AA batteries not included) and (1) (2) Cleaning Brushes Get also a carrying case, as it doesnt come with the kit. There's no difference between the Spectra S1 vs. Spectra S9 in terms of pump type. It's so much more quiet than many other pumps and you cannot beat the portability (unless you're willing to try the Willow or Elvie, but I'd like them to have new models to "work the kinks out" before I shell out that much money! The collection containers and the pump are all part of the same breast-shaped device that fits inside your bra and attaches to your breast. We researched and purchased well-loved and promising contenders to send through extensive hands-on testing to determine the best. We and our partners use cookies to Store and/or access information on a device. Cable). They are best suited for the sporadic pumper or occasional user. They are available in single (pump one breast at a time) and double (pump both simultaneously) versions, as well as popular designs that allow mom mobility while pumping. The Willow Gen 3 can get uncomfortable once you finish pumping as it continues to suck until you remove it (ouch!). So you must remember or at least write down the most efficient mode for you, so there will be less wasted time adjusting it when pumping. One potential drawback to the Buddha is that some users feel the suction is too powerful, particularly in the letdown phase. The rechargeable battery lasts for one hour of pumping and takes 3 to 4 hours to charge using a USB port. Weight: 210 gr. Noise level. Our exhaustive and detailed testing can give you the information you need to make a well-informed buying decision on your next breastfeeding friend. Its maximum is stronger than a Spectra! LIMITED TIME ONLY! The Baby Buddhas massage mode can be adjusted up to level 5 and has a range of 60mmHg 112.5mmHg. Baby Buddha vs Pumpables. Some things to consider in deciding which to get include cost, suction strength (if you struggle to empty I would suggest getting the Baby Buddha or Bella Baby, if you need something more gentle I would recommend S9 or Freemie), and how comfortable you feel . Overall, there is much to love about this efficient option, and we can't think of a good reason not to add it to your breastfeeding routine. I have the Spectra S1 as a primary pump (got secondhand for free from family member, never used), wondering which is a better secondary pump to get with insurance - Spectra S9 plus (free) or elvie Stride (100 upgrade). The BabyBuddha breast pump has an extra-soft cushion to prevent nipple soreness but most moms mentioned that the long pull on this system is really so painful. Manual pumps are hand-operated and pump one breast at a time via a flange and manual lever that creates suction via a simple squeeze and release operation to express milk. Privacy | Cookies | Terms, In Depth Baby Product Reviews Led by a Pediatrician. Not only is it a portable, quiet, efficient pump with new technology, it also has a great price! Our list of the ultimate nursing gear provides all the essentials regardless if you're exclusively breastfeeding or bottle-feeding your baby. I only recommend products I love! Ive thoroughly researched their features, its advantages and at times disadvantages and also added real feedback and online reviews from parents who have used the said products. 2. The Spectra 9 Plus Portable Breast Pump is slim and lightweight, and has a built-in rechargeable battery. The Baby Buddha is a tad more expensive than the Spectra S9 Plus. Some moms even said some blood came out while using the Baby Buddha and some wanted to cry out from the pain! One (1) Spectra 12-Volt AC Power Adapter. The light on the Mya is super bright, so I prefer the spectra at home. However, a good breast pump can be a considerable investment, and if you only plan to use it every once in a while, a simple manual product like the Medela Harmony will do the trick. Wendy breastfed both of her children and used more than one pump to help increase her milk supply and remain a working mother. (1) backpack pump bag with integrated cooler I'm still able to use the Baby Buddha plugged in (ugh) and the more I use it, the less crazy I am about it. If you need a mid- or low-priced option, one of the other options may be a better fit. At a fourth of a pound, the Baby Buddha is well-liked for its small size, design as a necklace, and being completely untethered while pumping. How would you compare the sound/volume while pumping? Closed systems are the best for hygiene, but the Willow goes a step further by expressing the milk directly into storage bags so there is less milk handling and potential for contamination. Two (2) Spectra Backflow Protectors. You can check out my Spectra 9+ review here. A breast pump is a nursing mother's second-closest companion during lactation, only outdone by her baby. Her education and professional and personal experience drive BabyGearLab standards and the product selection for this important review. (2) Milk Bottles Price: $ Portability should be high on your list if you plan to work or often travel with your pump. Let us know in the comments if you have any questions or thoughts on any of these pumps! Both the Baby Buddha vs Spectra S9 comes with their own complete set of accessories. (2) Pump Diaphragms The Haakaa earned the highest score for portability due to its minimal design. The pull is wayyyyy stronger than spectra! the baby buddha has 2 pump patterns. The Willow Gen 3 is also a wearable and a good choice for moms who need to be on their feet and in situations where structured break times are a struggle, like a busy ER. Gentler than some of the other portable options, May not be as powerful as some of the other options. So, the easier, the better! Wearability Ability to fit in a pocket, clip to your pants, wear around your neck, or wear in your nursing bra. . Compared to the other manual pumps on the market, the Medela has a unique "two-phase expression," very similar to many electric pumps in this review. Also, its the size of a phone pretty much, and chargeable. Its wireless, so no tubing, and everything is in your bra! Electric pumps do the hard work for you with variable suction and speed so you can get pumping done efficiently and simultaneously from both breasts. Instructions to Access Simply Breastfeeding and Breast Pumps Also, the minimal user interface only measures time in minutes, not seconds, which may or may not be a problem, as some competitors don't measure the time at all. Manual pumps that require frequent and repetitive hand motions can be taxing for many and impossible for some. Like all Spectra pumps, the S1 Plus You can even hang the Baby Buddha around your neck and keep your hands free to do work, clean the house, do chores or take care of your baby. BabyGearLab does not provide medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment.See our Terms for more info. Also, it's the size of a phone pretty much, and chargeable. Your post will be hidden and deleted by moderators. CaraCups are available in 24mm and 28mm sizes. Others said that the Spectra S9 Plus was a little loud for their taste. Rechargeable battery Not needing to be tied to an outlet is so freeing! BabyBuddha Smart & Rechargeable Breast Pump Unit (Black). Though it may take a bit of troubleshooting, many moms feel that this simple solution is well worth the extra effort once they get the hang of things, and we think this option is a budget-friendly solution for some moms who make a lot of milk. Baby Buddha - The Strongest Portable Breast Pump. Our experts have tested thousands of baby and kids products to share key performance, health, and safety findings. If you currently rely on breast compressions to pump much milk, you might struggle with a pump that collects milk in your bra, such as the Momcozy, Elvie, or Willow. (1) power adaptor with USB-C charging cable", 2 Air Tubes, 1 B-Connector, 2 Diaphragm Caps, 1 AC Adapter 1 USB Both breast pumps are equally sleek and portable. I was struggling with pumping with my spectra. The Spectra 1 is an easy to use, electric pump that works well and is whisper quiet. For the Spectra S9, check here if your insurance covers the said breast pump. When considering portability, the weight of the pump, the number of accessories, and overall size are factors in the equation. 1. Which means you cant share it nor resell it. I Feel It's More Stronger Than The S2. (2) 5oz/150ml bottles with lids Both the Baby Buddha and Spectra S9 Plus can be used as a double or single pump. Milk Genie Plus Vs Super Genie Breast Pump, Easy to see the milk spraying from the nipple, Easy to switch between double to single pumping. . The S1 has some serious suction power up to 270 mmHg, with a budget-friendly price. Transferring breastmilk after pumping is easy and sanitary. You need to make sure to turn it into the lowest setting letdown or massage mode before pumping, so it wouldnt hurt as much. think twice before sharing personal details, foster a friendly and supportive environment, remove fake accounts, spam and misinformation, delete posts that violate our community guidelines, reviewed by our medical review board and team of experts. The Elvie is very quiet, almost completely silent. Available vacuum level: 9 in expression mode, 5 in stimulation mode. It turns out that some electric pumps have very loud motors. I hope youll love the products we recommend! Spectra S9 vs Spectra S2, and Spectra S1 vs Medela. The Spectra S9 Plus weighs .5lbs or 0.23kg while the BabyBuddha is lighter and more compact, weighing only 0.04 kg, and is even smaller than an iPhone! (2) Duckbill Valves Continue with Recommended Cookies. (2) Tubing Adapter ends My first pump (first baby) was a Spectra S2. This pump is straightforward and intuitive to use, with only two buttons. However, if you need a gentler pump, I would go with the Spectra S9. Medela actively discourages moms from reusing or reselling previously owned breast pump equipment. The micro USB cable is just a simple one that you can easily replace it if you lose it. phthalates. If you take a while to empty and prefer stronger suction, you might like the Baby Buddha or the Bellababy. Its pretty straight forward and easy to clean. A trick working moms often use is to store used pump parts in a Ziploc bag or Tupperware container in the refrigerator until the next pumping session. Many people buy a portable pump as a second pump purchase, and already have a first pump/set of pump parts. your first time to pump. 99. Built-in battery last for one-hour pumping. If you are pumping several times a day while at work, washing pump parts after every session is definitely time-consuming and potentially embarrassing if you use the communal kitchen sink. . Ive tried both. Any feedback on which of the two is quieter when in use? We spend tens of thousands of dollars crash testing car seats to inform our ratings. Plus its so much smaller too! Each person has unique anatomy and milk supply, so finding what works best for you with suction strength and levels is essential. Its suction power has a mixed review, with some moms saying its powerful enough for them, while some are saying they cant get empty out their milk using this pump. It's the smallest and most compact breast pump by Spectra and among the lightest of all breast pumps. (2) 28mm Breast Shield Flanges I opted for the spectra s1. The Elvie is a bit limited in flange sizes 21mm, 24mm, and 28mm are available.